June 20, 2013

The GOP and Black Voters: Tell Me I'm Wrong

We have yet again another illustration of the GOP's fundamental problem in attracting the votes or support of African Americans. 

From the National Confidential website
A Republican party chairman in Montgomery County, Illinois, has been accused of sending a racist email.
In the email Jim Allen reportedly attacked Erika Harold, a former Miss America challenging Rep. Rodney Davis (R) in the party’s primary election. The email described Harold, who is biracial, as “the love child of the DNC” and that after the primary she’ll be “working for some law firm that needs to meet their quota for minority hires.”


It continues: “miss queen is being used like a street walker and her pimps are the DEMOCRAT PARTY and RINO REPUBLICANSThese pimps want something they can’t get,,, the seat held by a conservative REPUBLICAN Rodney Davis and Nancy Pelosi can’t stand it.”

Update: RNC Chairman Reince Priebus issued the following statement this afternoon calling for Allen's resignation:

“The astonishingly offensive views expressed by Chairman Allen have absolutely no place among the leaders of our party at any level. His behavior is inexcusable and must not be tolerated. He should apologize to Erika Harold and resign immediately.”

I applaud the chairman's action.  A standard must be set.

Update 2: Allen has resigned his leadership post as county chairman.

This type of rhetoric is another among many examples of my basic conclusion about the GOP and black voters, which I challenge ANYBODY to definitively refute. To wit;

The Republican party does not believe it needs black voters to win national elections and it conducts its political practice and messaging accordingly.

The Republican Party is fundamentally disinterested in black voters as a political constituency. The GOP does not believe that the black voter bloc is necessary or essential to its aspirations for governance. This is a sentiment widely held by both its national and state leadership and by the vast majority of its rank and file membership and supporters. 

I believe the above statement to be true and supported by ample behavioral evidence.  If you disagree, if you think that in fact the GOP is seriously interested in black voters as a political constituency and does believe them to be necessary and essential to their aspirations for governance, give me your argument for why the above statement isn't correct. 

Words of advice before you answer my challenge. CAREFULLY READ THE STATEMENT FIRST.  The above statement DOES NOT SAY the GOP is racist, so don't waste your time responding to it as though it does.  I've written it clearly and succinctly.  Address what it says.  That said, go ahead and make my day.  Tell me I'm wrong. 

Related articles
Enhanced by Zemanta

Comments (5)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
That chairman should just be fired. People like him are the reason why the Republican Party can't evolve beyond white Christian fundamentalists. Do you know what him and some Democrats have in common? They'd rather see the GOP die than have it evolve and become accepting of others. It's been said by Pat Buchanan as well as a few Democrats I know as well.

I've long wanted people like him to leave and form their own angry white people party. He also used the term "RINO" which I consider anyone to be an intolerant twit when they use that. It only brings more people to the Democrats.

It's things like this is why blacks don't consider the GOP.
I updated the post to reflect that RNC chair Preibus has called for his resignation and he has in fact stepped down, so thats a positive. It doesn't really address the underlying issue, but its a smart thing for the GOP to do if for no other reason than to protect its brand from this corrosive mess.
You're right it doesn't address the issue. The GOP not only has an issue when it comes to black voters, but a lot of groups as well.
Yes, I think thats true, certainly with Latino voters as well, its the same issue. Even the immigration reform efforts that Rubio is fronting don't really represent a change on this. Republicans are reacting to the 2012 loss and simply trying to get closer to 30% again, the kind of numbers that George Bush did. But beyond immigration, they are not going to engage that community of voters. The predictions from republicans that immigration reform won't do anything to bring hispanic voters to party may well be true, and it will be because reform on immigration is necessary but not sufficient. Without additional engagement, they can't give themselves a chance to win with this constituency either.
George W Bush, with his flaws, always tried to be inclusive. Simply changing immigration policy from "ship them all back home" ala Tom Tancredo to something like Rubio's plan won't work. Someone once said you have to be in the community all year round and not just election time.

Don't do it with just Latinos, but with every community all the time and honestly, just fire the strategists who say to ignore the ethnics and get people who have been in the communities. Simply nominating and getting candidates who resemble the group won't bring people over. Kicking the bigots out is a first step, but people won't flock suddenly. People like to be asked.

The Republican Party needs new ideas, not ideas that may have worked in the 80's. Unfortunately, it's all "Obama is a socialist, but we have the same old same old!"

Honestly, it needs a new base as it's had the same base for nearly 50 years. I speak as a concerned Rockefeller Republican.

Post a new comment

Comments by