Showing posts with label Wall Street. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wall Street. Show all posts

November 12, 2008

Bailing Out Detroit: Obama's Lose Lose Proposition

President Elect Obama was elected with a tremendous level of support from labor unions and they didn't do that for nothing. Unions have every expectation that their priorities will be addressed, chief among them looming large and in charge on the horizon, a bailout of the Detroit Dinosaur Triad. The Dinosaur Triad wants a $25 billion dollar "bridge loan", basically sidling up next to the Wall Street beggars crying poor mouth and hollering "me too".

From our man on the street perspective, this situation is why you have to ask Obama, why do you want this job? Basically, this seems like a lose lose deal. Do it, and you can bet that the Dinosaur Triad won't be the last industry to come rooting in the taxpayer trough. Where does it stop? And with every industry that gets a taste while the electorate watches friends and neighbor's mortgages one after the other bite the dust when their jobs go puff like smoke, the voter's anger will increase as we ask the reasonable question, "so where's my bailout? I made a bad decision or two, some honest mistakes and now I'm hurting pretty bad. Where's the help for me?".

Don't do it, and a major constituency, labor unions and the working class folk they connect to, take the hit as the Dinosaur Triad burns through its remaining cash in the next six months and begins laying off thousands and shuttering plants at home and abroad. Ditto for the industry of suppliers to the Dinosaur Triad too. The effect will ripple through the economy and across the kitchen tables of Joe and Jamaal Sixpack with the family destroying force of a nuclear blast wave. And with every family that takes it on the chin, flying apart in economic meltdown, divorce and family dysfunction maxed out by financial disaster, the voter's anger will increase as we ask the reasonable question, "so where's my bailout? I made a bad decision or two, some honest mistakes and now I'm hurting pretty bad. Where's the help for me?".

How in the world does Obama thread this needle? Economists and free market fiscal conservatives say, let the Triad die, the Phoenix that will arise from the ashes will be stronger and better, but there is no doubt that letting Detroit and the millions who make their livelihood from that industry implode by inaction would be political suicide as the labor unions and their followers turn and savage Obama like rabid dogs. Liberals and progressives will say save it, but that means our multi-trillion dollar deficit continues to grow like the blob, gorging and gobbling up our fiscal health and insuring our status as a debtor nation to the likes of China and the petro kingdoms continues for decades. I got family that works in the industry and I'll bet many of you do too, so this is personal.

What do we do?

October 2, 2008

We're Being Had and Here's the Proof - Call Congress and Tell Them - No Bailout!

Hat tip Politics After 50

Verification of the con game being run on the American taxpayer by Paulson and his Wall Street cronies comes via the contents of a secret conference call meeting on Sunday, Sept. 28th between Treasury Department officials and some 800 financial services industry insiders where they talk about how the additions to the bill that the Democrats "fought for" are just shams (CEO pay caps, metering out the $700 billion in smaller chunks, etc.). They can ALL be ignored or worked around.

Notes compiled by the blog Naked Capitalism are below on the call. Also, give THIS a read, watch the video below and then CLICK HERE TO SEND A LETTER TO YOUR CONGRESSMAN RIGHT NOW and tell them no way on this bailout con job.



The call:

Memo found at: http://dealbreaker.com/2008/09/treasury-to-hold-conference-ca.php
MEMORANDUM
TO: SIFMA Government Reps Committee
FR: SIFMA Washington Office
DA: September 28, 2008
RE: Conference Call w. Treasury / 9:00PM TONIGHT

At 9:00pm tonight, Sunday, September 28th, there will be a call with Treasury officials
to discuss the Troubled Asset Recovery Plan. This call is specifically for analysts.
Please distribute ASAP to analysts in your firm who might be interested in participating.
We have also distributed this call notice through various SIFMA Committees to solicit analyst
participation.

Please find the conference call information below:
Date: Sunday, September 28th
Time: 9:00PM ET
Toll-free Dial-in: 1-866-843-0890
Entry Code: 1812173#

Download the bit torrent recording of the call. The call has also been posted to Youtube in five parts.

There is a live blogging recap of the call at Dealbreaker.

Notes on the call from courtesy of Naked Capitalism
:

1. The tranching is a mere formality, and the Treasury boys as much as
said so. They could take the $700 billion max as soon as the bill has
passed,

2. However, they do not plan any action immediately,
will wait a couple of weeks. They want to focus their efforts on
stronger companies but also made noise about protecting the financial
system. This, by the way, is the Japanese convoy system all over.

3.There seemed to be a lot of tap dancing about what price they will pay
for assets and no straight answer about their policy on warrants. They
did say that if the amount sold was greater than $100 million, they
would take warrants. FYI, the current draft allows them to pay up to
the price at which the assets were initially booked (yikes) . I wonder
if this is obfuscation, if they have an idea of what the plan to do but
will not admit it in any public forum.

4. As the person who
listened to the call stressed, DealBreaker wasn't clear on the
bifurcated process. If you come to the Treasury and you are in trouble,
you get reamed. Bear/AIG style treatment, execs probably fired. But if
you participate on a voluntary basis, the intent is to make it very
user friendly. That is consistent with Paulson's position during the
negotiations.

5. The exec comp provisions sound like a joke,
They DO NOT affect existing contracts, they affect only contracts
entered into during the two years of the authority of this program and
then affect only golden parachutes. More detail on that point, but I
don't need more detail to get the drift of the gist.
Additional notes from the call compiled by Naked Capitalism:

1) If even the Treasury is saying tranching is a formality, then it really is nothing. Not sure why Dems fought so hard for a fig leaf.

2) Waiting a couple of weeks because no one has any idea when or where the next bomb will blow up. In other words, all their doomsday scenarios about Black Monday were B.S. They screamed the check had to be written by Monday, but now they're saying they actually have a few weeks before they need to cash it. Plus, this will allow them to "seek guidance" from GS, JPM, and other selfless public servants about where the money should be funneled.

3. The tap dancing is because they don't want it to get out that they'll be giving a sweetheart deal. The public won't be following each individual transaction to see exactly what price is being paid. So ridiculously overpriced asset sales can be hidden in the details, and by the time some reporter (or blogger :-) combs through and analyzes the transactions, the deed will have been done. But if Paulson makes a statement that assets will be bought at par before the bailout's even begun, that will be reported and might kill the deal.

4. In other words, we need to sweeten the pot to encourage banks to come "voluntarily". Pardon my ignorance, but why the hell should we be begging banks to borrow from us? I thought a bailout should be the absolute last option for a bank. I.e., it should be so unpalatable, so unprofitable for a bank and its executives that they exhaust every private means of survival before coming for their public "reaming". I wonder if foreclosed homeowners would rate their foreclosure process as "user friendly".

5. Of course the exec comp provisions are a joke. Who do you think is going to be hiring all those banking cmte staffers and newly retired congresspeople next year during the inevitable post-election turnover? Do you really think they're going to vote to limit their salaries?

October 1, 2008

The Jaundiced Eye of a Citizen or Kill the Bailout

Earlier this evening, Senators McCain and Obama voted for the Paulson bailout plan in the Senate, a plan essentially unchanged in its primary offensiveness from what Paulson originally proposed. We oppose the bailout. Intervention is necessary, but this is not the right solution set. Someone on POTUS 08 likened it to a fleet of ships on a lake. Some of them are sinking, and the response is to blow up the dam and drain the lake. The plan itself is the wrong solution and worse still, it is a wrong solution that will be implemented by the administration with some meddling by Congress, both of whom in the aggregate are a bunch of bumbling cretins.

Hunter @ Daily Kos captures my own sense of outrage well:

".....what this week has demonstrated more than anything else is that I, at least, have absolutely zero trust left that members of congress or the administration or the talking heads on the cable channels will ever, if left to their own devices, do the right thing.

I have lost absolutely all faith that any politician, anywhere, under any circumstances, when faced with the immediate presence of a lobbyist for the corporate world but only the vague, abstract premise of a public to be served, would make the right choice.

The underlying problem -- and you can think back on that lovely Bush administration interpretation of the "signing statement," for an example here -- is that whatever this $700 billion dollar bill looks like, it's going to be implemented in practice by some of the most corrupt and incompetent jackasses ever to grace the halls of power. We're talking about nearly a trillion dollars of money we don't have, which we are going to be indebted for into the far-distant future, to do nothing but patch the most immediate structural flaw of a market that, even when the flaw is patched, will be only barely functional."

This bailout is a sham solution to solve the self inflicted money problems of Wall Street firms unwilling to live with the consequences of their actions. Yes, there is a problem within the financial system, but there are prudent interventions to address that problem that do not carry the risks and pitfalls of the Bush-Paulson plan. We, the public, are being conned via the use of a false sense of emergency and crisis. Our legislators are being stampeded into providing a taxpayer funded windfall to the financial sector and they are either to stupid, too corrupt and bought off, or both to resist the siren call of Paulson and the lobbyists to pass this abomination of a bill. That goes for McCain and Obama too.

The American public knows its getting screwed. We've been communicating that to our legislators, but too many of them, aided by complicit media conglomerates, have decided that the public is too stupid to understand the problem. The fact is that our instincts that are screaming "this is BS" are right on the money. Call your legislators in the House and tell them don't pass the Paulson plan. Call your Senators and thank them if they voted no and to complain if they voted yes.

September 25, 2008

The McCain Gambit?

hat tip Race42008
“worst of all worlds he let Paulson and Bush drive bailout story for a week, then show up at a national security debate and have America think of him as the out of touch guy still hung up on the Surge. Now he is a leader, seeking to achieve bipartisan consensus to avoid catastrophe. He neutralizes Obama’s advantage because Obama has to fall in line behind the bailout Dodd will no-doubt drive through congress. Now economy is moot as they both support the same deal, only McCain is seen as a leader and Obama a follower. Debates resume next week, and McCain not seen as out of touch.”

September 24, 2008

McCain's Latest Gambit

McCain suspends his campaign to return to Washington to lead an effort for a bipartisan bailout of Wall Street. He's pushing this action as simply in line with his campaign motto - "country first".

I agree with Dave G. at Race42008:
1) The whole thing feels like a gimmick, and voters can intuit that. What voters infer from this move isn’t that McCain is putting country first, but that he’s attempting to utilize misdirection yet again to cover up what voters will assume to be McCain’s dearth of solutions regarding the economy. The campaign suspension becomes a political prop, much as Palin has become one, a woman who should be doing serious interviews about energy and growth with serious journalists. 4) But won’t McCain get momentum from showing leadership on the bailout? Probably not. The bailout is extremely unpopular with two groups McCain needs in November: conservatives, who see it as a market-corrupting scheme, and moderates, who see it as Washington once again putting special interests firsts.

Matthew makes an additional good point that McCain was facing bad options if he opposed the plan:

"So McCain will have put himself in the position of stopping a plan Democrats (and Bush) assured us would revitalize the economy, as the economy continues to go South. Total disaster. Realistically, he needed to do something he has never managed in the past; actually control a significant number of Congressional Republicans. That probably really does require him to do some hard ground work, twist some arms, etc."

They jointly make the case that McCain is being his mavericky self and putting country first and as a practical matter, he didn't have much of a choice if he really believed something has to be passed, but its clear republicans won't give it the votes.

Even if you go with that logic, the political benefits accruing to McCain if he is successful with this maneuver are plentiful:

  • Pushes debate schedule back and lets him do the foreign policy debate closer to the election, when presumably his better showing would have greater impact
  • Pushes back the VP debate, giving Palin more time for prep, possibly even scrapping the debate all together.
  • Gives him the newscycle for the next week, maybe even two if he plays it right and it really goes his way by having a consensus emerge over the weekend. This has the benefit of suppressing the Rick Davis lobbying story and the Palin affair scandal.
  • If he actually gets fellow republicans on board a compromise that they can throw in Obama and the Dem's face, he comes out looking like the leader and Obama looks ineffectual.
So there are lots of political reasons to make this move. I think the bailout is a bad idea. I think crafting legislation for a $700 billion dollar one over a weekend is a worse idea.

I don't think the debates should be cancelled. This feels like a stunt, especially if McCain can't really deliver on a compromise bill which I'm skeptical can be done given the copious amounts of republican antipathy to it. The issue is the question of walking and chewing gum at the same time. No need to suspend the campaign, thats why you have a running mate and 2nd. Seems to me if this is the strategy, now is a great time to put Palin front and center running the campaign while Maverick deals with the situation.

September 22, 2008

Newt on the Bailout Plan

Hat Tip Hot Air.

Before D.C. Gets Our Money, It Owes Us Some Answers [Newt Gingrich]

Watching Washington rush to throw taxpayer money at Wall Street has been sobering and a little frightening.

We are being told Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson has a plan which will shift $700 billion in obligations from private companies to the taxpayer.

We are being warned that this $700 billion bailout is the only answer to a crisis.

We are being reassured that we can trust Secretary Paulson "because he knows what he is doing".

Congress had better ask a lot of questions before it shifts this much burden to the taxpayer and shifts this much power to a Washington bureaucracy.

Imagine that the political balance of power in Washington were different.

If this were a Democratic administration the Republicans in the House and Senate would be demanding answers and would be organizing for a “no” vote.

If a Democratic administration were proposing this plan, Republicans would realize that having Connecticut Democratic senator Chris Dodd (the largest recipient of political funds from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) as chairman of the Banking Committee guarantees that the Obama-Reid-Pelosi-Paulson plan that will emerge will be much worse as legislation than it started out as the Paulson proposal.

If this were a Democratic proposal, Republicans would remember that the Democrats wrote a grotesque housing bailout bill this summer that paid off their left-wing allies with taxpayer money, which despite its price tag of $300 billion has apparently failed as of last week, and could expect even more damage in this bill.

But because this gigantic power shift to Washington and this avalanche of taxpayer money is being proposed by a Republican administration, the normal conservative voices have been silent or confused.

It’s time to end the silence and clear up the confusion.

Congress has an obligation to protect the taxpayer.

Congress has an obligation to limit the executive branch to the rule of law.

Congress has an obligation to perform oversight.

Congress was designed by the Founding Fathers to move slowly, precisely to avoid the sudden panic of a one-week solution that becomes a 20-year mess.

There are four major questions that have to be answered before Congress adopts a new $700 billion burden for the American taxpayer. On each of these questions, I believe Congress’s answer will be “no” if it slows down long enough to examine the facts.

Question One: Is the current financial crisis the only crisis affecting the economy?

Answer: There are actually multiple crises hurting the economy.

There is an immediate crisis of liquidity on Wall Street.

There is a longer time crisis of a bad energy policy transferring $700 billion a year to foreign countries (so foreign sovereign capital funds are now using our energy payments to buy our companies).

There is a longer term crisis of Sarbanes-Oxley (the last "crisis"-inspired congressional disaster) crippling entrepreneurial start ups, driving public companies private, driving smart business people off public boards, and driving offerings from New York to London.

There is a long term crisis of a high corporate tax rate driving business out of the United States.

No solution to the immediate liquidity crisis should further cripple the American economy for the long run. Instead, the liquidity solution should be designed to strengthen the economy for competition in the world market.


Question Two: Is a big bureaucracy solution the only answer?

Answer: There is a non-bureaucratic solution that would stop the liquidity crisis almost overnight and do it using private capital rather than taxpayer money.

Four reform steps will have capital flowing with no government bureaucracy and no taxpayer burden.

First, suspend the mark-to-market rule which is insanely driving companies to unnecessary bankruptcy. If short selling can be suspended on 799 stocks (an arbitrary number and a warning of the rule by bureaucrats which is coming under the Paulson plan), the mark-to-market rule can be suspended for six months and then replaced with a more accurate three year rolling average mark-to-market.

Second, repeal Sarbanes-Oxley. It failed with Freddy Mac. It failed with Fannie Mae. It failed with Bear Stearns. It failed with Lehman Brothers. It failed with AIG. It is crippling our entrepreneurial economy. I spent three days this week in Silicon Valley. Everyone agreed Sarbanes-Oxley was crippling the economy. One firm told me they would bring more than 20 companies public in the next year if the law was repealed. Its Sarbanes-Oxley’s $3 million per startup annual accounting fee that is keeping these companies private.

Third, match our competitors in China and Singapore by going to a zero capital gains tax. Private capital will flood into Wall Street with zero capital gains and it will come at no cost to the taxpayer. Even if you believe in a static analytical model in which lower capital gains taxes mean lower revenues for the Treasury, a zero capital gains tax costs much less than the Paulson plan. And if you believe in a historic model (as I do), a zero capital gains tax would lead to a dramatic increase in federal revenue through a larger, more competitive and more prosperous economy.

Fourth, immediately pass an “all of the above” energy plan designed to bring home $500 billion of the $700 billion a year we are sending overseas. With that much energy income the American economy would boom and government revenues would grow.


Question Three: Will the Paulson plan be implemented with transparency and oversight?

Answer: Implementation of the Paulson plan is going to be a mess. It is going to be a great opportunity for lobbyists and lawyers to make a lot of money. Who are the financial magicians Paulson is going to hire? Are they from Wall Street? If they’re from Wall Street, aren't they the very people we are saving? And doesn’t that mean that we’re using the taxpayers’ money to hire people to save their friends with even more taxpayer money? Won't this inevitably lead to crony capitalism? Who is going to do oversight? How much transparency is there going to be? We still haven't seen the report which led to bailing out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. It is "secret". Is our $700 billion going to be spent in "secret" too? In practical terms, will a bill be written in public so people can analyze it? Or will it be written in a closed room by the very people who have been collecting money from the institutions they are now going to use our money to bail out?

Question Four: In two months we will have an election and then there will be a new administration. Is this plan something we want to trust to a post-Paulson Treasury?

Answer: We don’t know who will inherit this plan.

The balance of power on election day will shift to either McCain or Obama. Who will they pick for Treasury Secretary? What will their allies want done? We are about to give the next administration a level of detailed control over big companies on a scale even FDR did not exercise during the Great Depression. Is this really wise?

For these reasons I hope Congress will slow down and have an open debate.

And in the course of that debate, I hope someone will introduce an economic recovery act that makes America a better place to grow jobs. I hope the details will be made public before the vote.

For more details on my action plan for getting the American economy back on track and building long-term economic prosperity, you can read this message recorded yesterday to American Solutions members.

This is a very important week for the integrity of the Congress.

This is a very important week for the future of America.

If Washington wants our money, then it owes us some answers.

March 23, 2008

Bear Stearns and the Fed Strategy

By George Friedman (Honorary Political Season Contributor)

The Federal Reserve System tried to reshuffle the financial deck late March 16. For the next 24 hours, the global financial markets tried to figure out where the Fed’s action left the system. At the end of the day, they were not happy. But at the same time, they were not suicidal. That represents a victory for the Fed.

It is important to understand what the Fed was trying to achieve. In essence, its goal was not complicated. It was trying to manage the collapse of a financial institution — Bear Stearns — such that it did not default on its clients, individual and institutional. The threat it faced was of bank failures, in which depositors would lose their savings. If Bear Stearns had been unable to carry out financial transactions on Monday morning because of a lack of cash, its clients effectively would have found their assets frozen. And that would have touched off a ripple through the financial system that might have caused a series of uncontrollable failures.

The Fed did two things to prevent this scenario. First, it engineered a buyout of Bear Stearns by JPMorgan Chase at $2 a share. The Fed was not at all interested in protecting investors in Bear Stearns, who were nearly wiped out. Nor were they interested in protecting Bear Stearns employees. The Fed was interested in having JPMorgan Chase — a huge bank with a strong balance sheet — in effect guarantee the liquidity of Bear Stearn’s account-holding clients, thus avoiding the threat of falling dominoes.

The Fed’s second move was to redefine the rules of access to low-cost, short-term financing from the Federal Reserve. Historically, such financing has been confined to banks. It has now been extended to brokerage houses. By doing this, the major brokerage houses can access money from the Fed for 90 days, up from 30. That sets the stage for an orderly consolidation of the system, in which major banks with strong balance sheets use short-term Fed money to acquire weak and failing institutions without having to pull liquidity out of the system by using their own money or trying to borrow money from banks. In effect, the Fed created a situation where other institutions in the same condition as Bear Stearns can be merged into healthier entities without the need for this weekend’s urgent scramble.

JPMorgan Chase got a pretty good deal out of the move. For less than a quarter billion dollars, it acquired the marketing strength and customer base of a major financial institution, something that could well be valued in the tens of billions once things settle down. We are not clear on what Bear Stearns’ debt structure was but its Manhattan building alone is said to be worth three times what Bear Stearns went for. Obviously there are a lot of liabilities traveling with Bear Stearns, but we suspect that given Fed financing, JPMorgan Chase was not engaging in charitable activity. Indeed, there already are rumors that Bear Stearns’ shareholders might resist the takeover. But by the time that happens, if it even does, the deal will be well down the road. In the meantime, its clients were served Monday morning.

The Fed is working to create a system for dealing with weak institutions that neither allows defaults to clients nor sucks liquidity out of the system as acquiring institutions raise money to make acquisitions. Just as the Fed effectively brokered this acquisition, we expect it to be brokering other ones in the coming days and weeks using its new tools. Alternatively, now that it is known that the Fed will protect clients as it would protect bank depositors, there will be fewer failures than otherwise. This is because the kind of pressure that built up on Bear Stearns last week may not happen again.

Those old enough to remember companies like Bache remember similar actions before. What the Fed has done is in fact not unprecedented. What is new is that it now regards brokerage houses and equity markets as being on par with banks and money markets. That is important, but not earthshaking.

The S&P 500 has shed about 20 percent of its value since October 2007. In 2000-2001, the S&P fell about 40 percent before beginning to recover — and the 2001 recession was not a transformative event. It was just another recession and a mild one at that. Obviously, the markets may continue to fall. But we are still struck by how well they are holding up in the face of remarkably negative sentiment and a sense of intense crisis.

We do not predict the market, but we do regard the equity markets as a guide to future behavior of the economy. Given negative sentiment and the failure to fall more than it has, it seems to us that the markets are saying that the liquidity crisis is being managed. For all the apparent gloom, the markets are doing surprisingly well. Between this liquidity crisis, soaring oil prices and the falling dollar, the equity markets are in fact remarkably calm. But that is a leading indicator and it might change on a dime.

We continue to believe that petrodollars and Chinese dollars are stabilizing the American system. And the Fed now has reduced the threat of structural failure of financial institutions. As we have said, a recession is to be expected after six years of expansion. But the latest actions by the Fed strike us as evidence that while a recession may be likely, it won’t be catastrophic.