Showing posts with label history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label history. Show all posts

October 13, 2009

How Not To Sell A Minority Point of View


A member of my FB circle posted this PSA. I'm all for more accurate, non distorted readings of history. If you don't understand the past, blah blah blah. But this group or coalition of groups is trying to sell two different outcomes that really ought not to be conflated with each other, as they do with this PSA and website:

Outcome#1: Eradicate Columbus' name from the federal calendar.

I kid you not, its stated just that way on their website.
So you start your campaign by seeking to tear down something long established, without having laid a sufficient foundation in education or outreach to change peoples viewpoint about this historical figure. Further, this stance is not necessary, they could have just stayed with the soft kill approach of getting out the alternate historical viewpoint on Columbus. But they are so busy trying to make people feel like crap over Columbus Day, so busy being self righteous they don't get the more important issue of correcting the historical record right. That alternate history should be front and center when you hit this link. If you are going to lambaste Americans as perpetuating racism with Columbus Day, your take on the history should be the FIRST thing I see when I hit this site to back up the fact that you're calling me out as an oppressor for taking any part in Columbus Day.

The tactical decision to essentially vilify people who celebrate or otherwise recognize Columbus Day is the strategic blunder here. Those folks are not doing that to insult native peoples or "perpetuate a philosophy of racism and domination". Its just flipping Columbus Day to the average American, but this bunch turns them into monsters by essentially saying "Columbus was a monster. If you celebrate Columbus Day, you condone heinous crimes against native people. You're a monster too".


Outcome#2:
Honor the people who were really here first by petitioning for a nationally recognized Indigenous holiday.

This sounds like a good thing. I'm not sure there are a lot of people who would disagree with it. Oddly enough, even people who believe in white supremacy have a measure of respect for native peoples history of resistance and some of the storied ways and traditions of native peoples. Most Americans of all colors brag a little about having native blood in their ancestry. Further, most Americans are on board to one degree or another with the concept that we took the land from the native peoples of America and we were not particularly nice about it. There is a level of residual guilt on this score, kept somewhat fresh by the historical presence of reservations. I don't think you have to work that hard to get this. But the goof here is that these folks conflate their two desired outcomes when they should have remained wholly separate. Making eradication of Columbus Day from the federal calendar synonymous with honoring native peoples puts the two things together in a completely unnecessary way.

An exit note: I had to dig through several links to get to anything that seemed to provide the alternative historical information that this PSA seeks to highlight. When I did get to something, it was a table of contents for a "Rethinking Columbus" set of teaching materials. In looking at it, it further confirms the bull in a china shop approach. These materials seem more likely to be useful for an audience of people who largely agree with the native viewpoint, not for convincing other people to think and educate their children differently.

As a campaign for changing people's minds, I think the Reconsider Columbus Day campaign is a whole lot of fail.


January 22, 2009

I'll Say It: Rev. Lowery Behaved Like A Jackass

Sometimes, there just is not time to get something said that needs saying at the time it needs saying. So it is with my post inauguration reactions. I'm a little late to the party and still pressed for time, so I'll be relatively brief:

Rick Warren's Invocation: He did not bring it. The guy is a pastor and preacher over a mega church congregation. I expected and wanted a prayer that called on God in a manner that was equal to the moment and the nation's need. I wanted a prayer that would have been the equivalent of a national alter call to service to God and country. As a former member of a mega-church (Word of Faith, pastored by the awesome Bishop Butler) I have heard awesome mega church pastor preaching and prayer. I sooo expected Warren to bring it at that level, but brother had no cadence, no rhythm and as one of my friends remarked, too much emphasis on the "first black president" aspect. A completely underwhelming prayer effort, though I'm sure God heard it just fine.

The Oath: Mr. Chief Justice, you are a constitutional scholar, the chief justice of the court and oh by the way, the 35 words of the oath are in the damn constitution. Is it too much to ask that on such a history making inauguration and your first of many at bat, that you would get that right? Not only did you flub it, but yesterday, out of an "abundance of caution" the oath was re-administered to Obama, something that has happened only twice before. Not quite epic fail, but approaching the frontier. Exit thought on this: how cheesed off are the natural born citizen truthers now? The court summarily rejects all their appeals and the Chief Justice swears The Messiah twice to make sure it sticks!

The Inaugural Composition: I thought the composition created for the inauguration was a wonderful piece of music and Yo-Yo Ma seemed positively full of joy to play it. I thought he gave a real gift to the nation in the performance of the piece. It was a lovely piece of music totally in keeping with the spirit of the event.

The Inaugural Poem: To be fair, I watched the inauguration with my children at their school and I had to take take my son to the bathroom right about the time of the poem, so I didn't get a solid hearing of it and I will look and listen to its rendition again. That said, I'm sorry, it was deadly dull boring, I didn't really understand it and it was spoken in about as deadpan, lifeless and joyless a manner as one could imagine. If Yo-Yo Ma was the epitome of joy in rendition, the poet was the total opposite. I could have been more inspiring than that. Epic Fail.

The Benediction: I didn't mind Lowery's vernacular exposition or the inclusion of the negro anthem so much. It grated my nerves, however I could live with it. But the protest song bit at the end - totally inappropriate to the moment. Old Civil rights coots like him simply cannot let go of racial grievance. He just could not resist the opportunity to tweak the white man at this historical moment. Could not get over himself and the racial history to get out of the way and let this be a moment not just for black American people but for the American people. Complete jackass behavior in my opinion and a real embarrassment to disparage white people in such a blanket way at the inauguration of the 1st black president who got elected with a WHOLE lot of white votes, but he just HAD to slap those folks in the face with his race/victim shtick.

Obama did his level best to let the campaign be about his ideas, not his skin color and at the moment of triumph, Lowery cannot be content to let the victory and the self evident achievement speak for itself. It was unnecessary, unwarranted, and beneath the dignity of the moment. Lowery is an elder, whom we should respect, and he's a civil rights warrior who looked in the face of segregation back in the day. But with all due respect, being an elder ought to mean you have gained some wisdom as well, and that you employ it in your life. The inauguration of the 1st black president was not the time to wear racial grievance on his sleeve or indict white America however gently or mildly some may have regarded it. Some have defended his words as an artful way to honor the occasion and I totally disagree. I think he was simply unable to resist the opportunity to rub it in white America's face just a little and that he in essence gave in to the smaller, less charitable part of his character in doing so. It marred, for me, what was an otherwise very dignified moment of history.

That's my take, what say you? Am I right or way off base? Say it like you feel it.

July 8, 2008

Black Patriotism: The Blood of Heroes

During World War I on the first day of the draft, 700,000 African American men signed up.

Pictured at left: Members of the 369th Infantry Regiment, popularly known as the Harlem Hellfighters. The 369th Infantry Regiment was known for being the first African-American Regiment during WWI. One Medal of Honor and many Distinguished Service Crosses were awarded to members of the regiment. The most celebrated man in the 369th was Pvt. Henry Lincoln Johnson, a former Albany, New York, rail station porter, who earned the nickname "Black Death" for his actions in combat in France. In May 1918 Johnson and Pvt. Needham Roberts fought off a 24-man German patrol, though both were severely wounded. After they expended their ammunition, Roberts used his rifle as a club and Johnson battled with a bolo knife. Johnson was the first American to receive the Croix de Guerre. By the end of the war, 171 members of the 369th were awarded the Legion of Honor

This historical note is merely one singular reminder that the patriotic bona fides of African Americans have been sealed in the blood of heroes during every American conflict in our country's history.

February 5, 2008

God Speed Obama


Today is Super Tuesday. 24 states across the nation will go to the polls to cast their votes for the nominee they want to represent the respective parties in the general election. Among the candidates contending for that vote is Barack Obama, the senator from Illinois, the state of my birth, a black man vying to become President of the United States and in so doing, make American history.

I listened last night to Harold Ford Jr. the current DNC chairman, on the Charlie Rose show arguing the merits of today's vote producing a clear winner and talking the merits of both candidates out of one side of his mouth while slyly slanting his commentary in Hillary's favor out the other. He was one of the early Obama critics, publicly stating that an Obama win of the nomination would mean the party's defeat in the general. He has been among a group of critics such as Tavis Smiley, damning Obama with faint praise. Or those of the black democratic establishment, like Andrew Young, who have told Obama "wait your turn boy'.

All these haters that Barack has had to contend with. And look at him now. Barack has run a damn effective campaign, raised $132 million, won 2 primaries and been competitive in all, and is now poised to potentially win an insurgent victory in today's Super Tuesday contests. He has accomplished this against the entrenched political machine of the most accomplished political duo in democratic history who have dominated democratic politics for over a decade.

Its easy to forget dear reader that a scant 45 days ago, Hillary's victory was all but assured. It was a coronation ceremony, not a nomination contest. The Iowa caucus earthquake was January 5th people! Now Obama is surging, victory nearly within his grasp.

I've made the case here and elsewhere that African Americans should support Obama's run, win or lose, because he is qualified, credible and bonus, he's black. There is no down side to giving him our support. What he has done, what he is doing, lifts up Black America. His run, his example, his history, his family, his identity, his leadership.....is a credit to us. He has done us proud. We've supported and are supporting so many buffoons and charlatans. In Detroit, they are retaining a black mayor who's behavior is shameful and egregious. Contrast that to Obama. In New Orleans, a congressional representative who banks his bribes in the freezer still has a job. Contrast that to Obama. If Obama is an embarrassment, it is an embarrassment of riches. He, and the woman by his side, Michelle Obama, an accomplished woman in her own right, are giving us every day an example of excellence and accomplishment in motion. Michelle epitomizes class, intelligence, judgment, and commitment. She grounds his achievement, leavens his ambition and inspires him to his highest self, and she is doing that for us as well. You could not ask for a more distinctive First Lady.

So today as the Super Tuesday battle looms large and even as I write these words, millions of voters across the country are casting their votes. In this pivotal moment, as potentially another step towards history is made, I want to pause and say well done Barack. You are a credit to us. You have gone farther than your predecessors and you may go further still. I applaud your success and your commitment. I cheer you because you are not doing it alone, you are bringing us with you. I commend you because you are setting a standard that will guide those who come after you, doing both a service to our present and our future, no matter the outcome. I wish you victory on every electoral battlefield this day.