Showing posts with label law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label law. Show all posts

June 3, 2009

Sotomayor: Impartial Enough

Newt Gingrich today backs away from his intemperate and foolish branding of Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor as a racist. I have often made the point that in American discourse we have thrown the word "racist" around so indiscriminately for so long that it is now almost useless as terminology for purposes of reasoned discussion. We have no clarity as to what the heck we mean when we say it. Black people brought this about by near reflexive application of the term to circumstances which did not warrant it and now it is injudiciously thrown around by everybody, including people like Newt who certainly should know better. But that's a subject for a different post. Back to the issue at hand.

Newt's underlying assumption and assertion in this opinion piece is that judges carry out their duties from the bench with impartiality, entirely unaffected by their life experience or their identity. I disagree with this underlying premise. The exercise of judgment by those on the appellate bench is NOT completely impartial and unaffected by their life experience and identity, no more so than was the writing of the law which they interpret. That is a fiction.

The issue is whether Sotomayor will be influenced in the exercise of her judgment by these factors to some extent greater than is the case with the typical judge on the federal bench. In other words, every judge is influenced by their identity and life experience. We expect that influence to be mediated by their fidelity to a fair application of the law and there is a band of judicial behavior on the bench within which we expect judges to constrain the influence of their identity and life experience. The issue is whether or not Sotomayor in her career on the bench routinely operates outside of these norms in a manner that makes her unsuitable to serve on the Supreme Court. The answer to that question is clearly no.

Newt admits as much when he says..

"In fairness to the judge, many of her rulings as a court of appeals judge do not match the radicalism of her speeches and statements. She has shown more caution and moderation in her rulings than in her words."

In fairness to the judge indeed. We have a multitude of opinions from the bench upon which to assess whether Sotomayor applies the law with impartiality. We don't have to guess or speculate. Review the opinions. There is no reason to believe that the Judge Sotomayor seen on the appellate bench in nearly 400 opinions will be any different than the Justice Sotomayor who will appear at the High Court. Even her critics admit, as Newt does here, that her appellate judicial record gives every indication that she interprets the law in a reasoned and impartial manner. She is clearly qualified. Confirm her.

July 1, 2008

Contrasts in Justice: Joe Horn & John White

Stop. Don't read the post yet. Just check the visuals. Sorta telegraphs the outcome and damn if I'm not just plain weary of that.

A Pasadena, TX grand jury has declined to indict Joe Horn on any criminal charges stemming from a Nov. 14, 2007 incident when he shot and killed two black hispanic men who were robbing his neighbors home. Horn observed the robbery taking place from inside his home and called the police. Despite repeated instructions from the police dispatcher to remain in his home, Horn insisted on going outside and confronting the thieves. When he attempted to stop them, they tried to run and Horn shot each one in the back with his shotgun, killing them both.

This stands in stark contrast to the fate of 53-year-old John White, convicted of manslaughter and now serving time for the August 9, 2006 killing of 17-year-old Daniel Cicciaro during a confrontation in the front yard of White's home. Cicciaro and his friends had come to intimidate and potentially assault Aaron White, John's son. They called his home and told him they were coming for that purpose. John and his son armed themselves and waited, rather than calling the police. When the guys arrived, they confronted them and in the ensuing confrontation, John White shot Cicciaro in the face, killing him.

The white man in Texas who confronted burglars robbing his neighbor's house completely unnecessarily killing two men with shotgun blasts to the back will not face a single charge or consequence, and in fact is lauded as a hero on many fronts, though in fairness the City of Pasedena appears to at least have some awareness that this result is not quite right.

The black man who confronted a group of teens in his own front yard, teens who called his home at least 30 minutes in advance to say they were coming to physically harm his son and who rather than call the police, armed himself and waited for them to arrive to confront them, and shot a foolish, perhaps malovelent teenager? He's in jail, serving a maximum term of 5 to 15 years in prison.

In both of these cases, the shootings were not justified in my opinion. Both men had ample opportunity to avoid harm and allow the authorities to address the situation. In both cases, each man chose confrontation and reckless, unnecessary self help tactics to address the situation with tragic results. Both should have faced a consequence. The results of the justice system handling of these two cases has been depressingly predictable in its disparity of result.

Do you agree with me? Aren't both of these guys wrong? Or were they both justified? Or have the courts sorted it out correctly?

May 26, 2008

Free At Last

Flanked by a family member on the left and Innocence Project attorney Barry Scheck on the right, Walter Swift looks out at the world from the steps of the Frank Murphy Hall of Justice in Detroit on Wednesday, May 21, 2008 as a free man. Swift was freed after spending 26 years in jail for a rape he didn't commit.

I'm interested in solutions for black America. Clearly, reform of the justice system in this country is needful, because Walter's story occurs too often. And for every Swift that the Innocence Project frees, there are another 20 or more that never get the light of justice shined on their situation. The Innocence Project worked for 11 years to free Swift. 11 damn years. The man languished in prison for a decade before someone began to look into his case, and another decade of his life came and went in prison while the battle was fought. Its a terrible injustice. The Innocence Project isn't just working on the cases of the wrongly convicted, they have also assembled information about the kinds of policy reforms which would reduce the number of people who are wrongly convicted in the first place.

The reforms that can address and prevent wrongful convictions include: As always, when I look at whats needed to bring about real, lasting changes on substantive issues, I'm struck by the fact that the work that must be done is tedious, costly and decidedly unsexy. Its not marches or protests (they have their place), its organization, fund raising and long term activism to marshal people power and deploy human and political capital. The issues above don't get solved or fixed without hard, dogged effort over time.

Walter Swift hugs his daughter Audrey Kelly Mills, 27. She was an infant when Walter went to prison. He has not seen or touched her during her life until the day this picture was taken.

Visit the Innocence Project. Learn more about the issues and get involved. Because God forbid that you or I or someone we love should ever need an Innocence Project in the first place.